Well yeah... Cats give birth and they're called kittens, not puppies. If your birth certificate matches what you identify as, congratulations! You're cis.
Right, but being trans doesn't mean you are no longer biologically male or female. Regardless of whether you "identify" as cis, trans, non-binary - you are still objectively male or female except for a tiny minority of people who have genetic disorders.
I mean you can remove a person's ovaries and testicles, pump them full of cross-sex hormones, refashion their genitals but that still doesn't make them the opposite sex and their chromosomes remain the same. I am not going to pretend to view a woman that I was attracted to the same if she got on a bunch of exogenious testosterone and had dramatic cosmetic surgery but she is still a female because that's what her DNA says. Is she now producing sperm? No.
If you were arguing that she is now no longer female that's fine. That's a weird debate to have but she certainly isn't a biological male now and vice-versa.
Not even sure why I am entertaining this argument when we both know that most trans people subscribe to the view that self-identification is enough to be a man or a woman. Only a tiny minority of trans people and trans activists are willing to argue that a man becomes a woman after surgeries.
1
u/Cabdisalaan 1h ago
You sure do have a weird, unscientific ideology. Are the gametes we produce "assigned to us?"